The “Get a Second One Free” Marketing Ploy

The “Get a Second One Free” Marketing Ploy

As Seen on TV advertisements almost always end with the familiar spiel at the end: Buy one, get one free – just pay additional processing and handling. It’s standard practice for marketing As Seen on TV products, and for good reason: it virtually guarantees they won’t lose money.

Sponsored links

If you purchase an As Seen on TV product – and decide to keep it – the company profits from selling the product and the extra money they charge for “processing and handling” above the actual shipping costs. If you decide to return the product, however, they’ll still profit. This is because the total cost of shipping, marketing, materials of these products is often equal to or less than the shipping and handling (or processing) charges of a single unit. And, unlike the product itself, the “processing and handling” is non-refundable.

The True Cost

In our research, we’ve found that the total cost of most As Seen on TV products – including production, marketing, packaging, and shipping – tends to be approximately the amount they charge for “processing and handling” for one item. Sometimes less. This means that the cost they charge you for the item itself is all profit, so even products with extremely high return rates are still profitable.

When they throw in the “get a second one for separate processing and handling,” they’ve simply increased their bottom line with very little extra cost to them.

Cheap Materials

The most common complaint among dissatisfied customers who have purchased As Seen on TV products is that they are cheaply-made. One would presume that this is because the weight and materials must be kept to an absolute minimum in order to keep shipping costs as low as possible. A $19.95 product sold on television might only cost the company a dollar or two in bulk from a Chinese factory.


If you pay $19.95 for a gizmo, then tack on $7.95 P&H and then another $7.95 for your second “free” product, you’ve just paid a total $35.85 for something that may have cost them $4 to produce, plus a couple more bucks to package and ship. Your second “free” item is usually boxed up with the first one, so additional costs for shipping and packaging is minimal. Even if you decide to return the items, they’ve still profited $10-$14 for the “processing and handling” you paid them.

Money Back Guarantee

The money-back guarantee exists to try to “prove” to you that the company believes in their product. It’s an influential marketing technique, and advertisers know that many people – even those dissatisfied with the product – won’t bother with the hassle of using it.

Should you decide to take advantage of the money back guarantee, it can be a frustrating due to low-end customer service farmed out to the lowest bidder.

Lifetime Warranty

Offering a “lifetime warranty” is yet another ploy to “prove” that a company believes in its product. Most of these products – and the companies that sell them – aren’t around for a lifetime.  Even if parent companies still exist, finding anyone to honor its lifetime warranty is almost impossible once a product is retired.

Sponsored Links

Slow Shipping

Most As Seen on TV products require an inordinate amount of time to be delivered. This allows them to use the cheapest method of shipping available to them. It also allows them to charge extra to “expedite” shipping, which is also inflated to earn them additional profits. Many of our readers have complained that “expedited” shipping seemed to take just as long as regular shipping.

Marketing Hype

An added benefit of the “get a second one free” pitch is that they can advertise a lower price than they’re actually charging you. You’ll often see, “You get it all for just $19.95.” But $19.95 ends up being closer to $36 when 2x shipping is included. Or more.

Shipping and Handling vs Processing and Handling

In recent years there has been a transition from the phrase “shipping and handling” to the more vague “processing and handling.” Neither is really defined, and they are used interchangeably. One could argue that, in a $7.95 shipping/processing fee, it may cost $3 to ship, and nearly $5 for someone to put it in a box and attach a label.

Bottom Line

There are times, however, that an As Seen on TV product ends up actually garnering positive reviews. In those cases, it’s often best to wait until it arrives on store shelves, then purchase it locally to avoid the hassle of shipping costs and delays.

It could be argued that the true product some As Seen on TV marketers are trying to sell is actually the non-refundable “processing and handling.” And as an extra bonus, you’ll even get a cheaply-made, over-hyped product thrown in for good measure.

Further Reading

Updated January 21, 2016
Originally published July 2013

  • Stan Wofford

    “… and if you act now you get a second flashlight free… just pay a separate fee…”

    do people bite…?

  • BJV

    What mystifies me is why the FTC doesn’t have a regulation preventing this obvious scam. The Feds seem to have regulations forevery other profitable activity.

  • Timothy Campbell

    For just $9.95 you can get a free Certificate of Authenticity, attesting to the authenticity of the certificate. Our expert staff examine each and every Certificate to ensure that it is of the highest-quality authenticity. Order now and get two for the prices of one, or order five for the price of four! Please add $9.95 per certificate for processing, testing, folding, carrying and our exclusive aging process. Order now. Order immediately! Order! Now! Only 100 left, approximately, so hurry! Hurry! Hurry! Order hurry order now hurry now.

    Not available in stores.


More in Consumers

Celebrating the weird and fake since 2008.

Copyright © 2008-2016, Inc. Theme by MVP Themes, powered by Wordpress.