The 2008 Republican campaign dealt a well-deserved blow to the Religious Right of the Republican party. But didn’t they see it coming? The presumed front-runner throughout all of 2007 was Rudy Giuliani, who was the only vocal pro-choice candidate. After his disastrous wait-for-Florida strategy put him out of the race, we were left with Mormon Mitt Romney, moderate and 2000 also-ran John McCain, and ordained Baptist minister Mike Huckabee. With a split in evangelical votes, McCain surprised everyone on the right and pried the nomination away from the right wing of the party.
For the record, I am a Republican. A moderate, and proud of it.
The likes of Rush Limbaugh and Ann Coulter are beside themselves with no “true” conservative to support. In other words, McCain doesn’t pander to the right wing of the party. This is supposed to be a bad thing?
What the Religious Right fails to realize is that they are not the only Republicans. There are fiscal conservatives and social conservatives. It’s not always a happy marriage.
Why is it that whenever a moderate Republican is poised to be President, we hear how he has to appease the conservatives. Why is that? Why don’t we ever hear how a conservative has to appease the moderates? Rush Limbaugh recently stated that conservatives are the base of the party, implying that they somehow earn special treatment. He also said that moderates are essentially those who can’t make up their minds.
It’s rarely fiscal or foreign policy issues that split the Republican party, but social issues. Evangelicals have an agenda that extends far beyond politics and can be found in the pages of the Holy Bible. So much for separation of church and state? Even conservative hero Barry Goldwater warned for years of religion crossing over in to politics.
Let’s consider two imaginary Republicans: a non-church going CEO of a large company, and a deeply religious middle-class school teacher. Both are Republicans, but for completely different reasons. The CEO wants tax breaks, and business-friendly politicians in office. Abortion is probably the last thing on his mind. He might even be pro-choice, but it isn’t an issue he votes on. The teacher could care less about business friendly politicians, but wants someone who will represent his core values, one of them being a pro-life stance.
The Religious Right cries of being persecuted and discriminated against, yet they are often the ones with the most power. If a minister walked into a room of atheists and said he believed in God, he’d probably be ignored. If an atheist walked into a room of believers and expressed his disbelief, he would find a crowd of believers attempting to “save” him from his belief.
It’s the Republican party, not the Christian Party or the Religious Party. Secular Moderates have every reason to be Republicans and to strongly believe whatever they desire. And just because they happen to agree with the Religious Right on fiscal and foreign policy issues, doesn’t mean that they embrace every element of the party platform.
Most Republicans believe in state’s rights, smaller government, lower taxes, strong defense, a free-market system, oppose labor unions, and wish to halt the avalanche of illegal immigration into our country. I rarely find a Republican who doesn’t agree on all of those issues.
On the other hand, social issues such as prayer in public school, teaching creationism, abortion, and a rejection of stem cell research are brought to the tables for religious reasons alone.
Prayer in public school
I just don’t get this one. If someone wants to bow their head and silently say a prayer, more power to them. Why does this have to be legislated? It was never a problem when I was a kid… and there was no prayer in school. If someone wanted to pray to himself, no one minded either way.
Teaching creationism
If you take the Genesis fable out of the picture, where else can scholars go to learn of this? What do you want a science teacher to say? “Some people believe that God created man, I just have no evidence or scientific data to back this theory up.” Or should he just go grab the Bible and start reading Genesis? Even some Christians have jumped off the creationism bandwagon and call it an allegory. Problem is that Jesus traced his lineage back to Adam.
Abortion
This is a big issue promoted by modern Christians via Biblical interpretation. I won’t go into it here, but you can easily debate if aborting a few cells early in a pregnancy amounts to “murder” as outlined in the Bible. Recent polls suggest that around 60% of Americans think abortion should be legal in some or all cases. A full 70% of Americans said they would vote for a president if they agreed with all issues except abortion with him. In other words, this is a big issue with evangelicals, but most people are content with abortion being legal.
Same Sex Marriage
There is mention of homosexuality being wrong in the Bible, so I actually understand why someone who believes the Bible will be against this. This leads me to something my cousin said to me today… If Christians want to stop being “persecuted” (as they think they are), they should stop trying to tell everyone else what to do. With same sex marriage – who really cares what two consenting adults choose to do? I know… Christians feel that acceptance of this will lead to moral decay and doesn’t preserve the values by which our country was founded. Of course many of these same Christians by no means follow the Bible to the letter… but they certainly are willing to take the moral reins, flaws and all, and lead those of us they deem morally impotent around. Why are these hypocrites so set on forcing their set values – which they themselves often break – down everyone else’s throats?
I attended the Nevada Republican Caucus this year. Each precinct had its own meeting, and people from each pricinct were asked if they wanted to say anything about the candidates they supported. A woman got up and started talking about Mike Huckabee, and said, “He represents the evangelical views that I hold…” I looked around and noticed some people lit up like a Christmas tree, while others rolled their eyes. The Republican divide is real.
Should McCain win the election, it will be interesting to see if evangelical Republicans can twist his arm enough to make him take a couple steps to the right. Arm twisting (among other things) didn’t work in the Hanoi Hilton, but maybe 40 years later he’ll crack.